My ready response to that is this: What would you say if you saw an eighteenth century reenactor using chopsticks? Certainly stripping the bark from two sturdy twigs would not have been beyond the technology of the day. Is it likely that some frontiersman could develop the technique to use them effectively? That I cannot say, but it is not impossible. True, disproof of something's absence is not the same as proof of its existence. But certainly somebody could have made one, or had one made using the tools and materials available at the time. But I digress.
I must have owned a dozen short starters over the years. Unlike most shooters, I had a possibles bag for every caliber I owned. They were even color coded with a string of glass beads; red indicated .45, white for .50, and blue for .54. Everything contained in the bag was caliber appropriate, so I was essentially equipping myself in triplicate. When I acquired a trade gun I added a fourth. Currently I have only one bag and one short starter, and only change a leather ball bag and the can of pre-cut ball patches suitable for .50 and .54 round balls. In a small tin box I keep cleaning patch jags for all three calibers, along with some other bits. But I carry only one short starter, and the one I chose may surprise some shooters. It is actually a pistol cleaning rod with a non-removable, 8/32 threaded .45 jag.
This proved to be a very practical solution because when loading a pistol, the process of changing from a short starter to a ramrod simply wastes time. Combining both functions into one tool is more efficient. The integral .45 cleaning jag allows me to easily clean any .45 pistol I shoot, and can convert if to a .50 or 54 cleaning rod by simply threading on a different caliber jag. There is another advantage that is not so obvious; the increased length of the rod allows the short starter to hang from a loop more securely. It slips easily into a leather loop I attached to the side of my possibles bag. Easy in, easy out.I further customized the short starter by sanding a flat spot opposite to the short starting plug. It hurts less to pound on a flat surface than to engage the rounded contour of the unmodified ball. I filed a groove in the side of the ball to prevent bumping into the ramrod if it isn't fully seated in the stock. There's a photo at the end of this post.
If this approach appeals to you, this loading rod is still available through Track Of The Wolf. Honestly, their website is far better for ordering newly manufactured items, while the perennial favorite, Dixie Gun Works, carries a much wider variety of parts, even stocking some original parts for popular flint and percussion actions. A third option is the Gun Works in Springfield Oregon, which is still a personal favorite because of their incredible customer service.
In my next post I'll be talking about possibles bags and powder horns. I also want to give a shout out to the late Ron Griffin, a local shooter who was the first to encourage me to practice "loading from the pouch", since all rendezvous shooting would be done from the standing position and without a bench to work from.
Here's a photo of my flattened short starter ball. The short starter plug is on the opposite side of the flat. Much less ouch.


